Inquirer : Is stoning an Islamic punishment
Mullah pet : Yes it is
Inquirer : Is it in the Quran
Mullah pet : No but it is in the Hadith (Sold as "sayings" of the the Prophet Pbuh)
Inquirer : Did the Prophet Pbuh actually said so ?
Mullah pet : Well not exactly but others report that this was the practice.
Inquirer : So the Prophet Pbuh never actually said to replace the 100 lashes of the Quranic punishment for adultery with stoning.
Mullah pet : If his companions said so it is good enough for me.(classified as anyone who saw the Prophet Pbuh)
Inquirer : Since Hadith literature is sold as not contradicting the Quran, what are the basis for changing the clearly worded verse on this particular subject?
Mullah pet : Abrogation of course
Inquirer : And in that case there must be dozens of Hadith to support this game changing notion of abrogation right?
Mullah pet : Well actually, no there are no Hadith to support abrogation but our Mullahs say so.
Inquirer: So basically what you are saying is that a group of Mullahs can in practice overrule the Quran ?
Mullah pet: You are a Kafir
Mullah pet : Yes it is
Inquirer : Is it in the Quran
Mullah pet : No but it is in the Hadith (Sold as "sayings" of the the Prophet Pbuh)
Inquirer : Did the Prophet Pbuh actually said so ?
Mullah pet : Well not exactly but others report that this was the practice.
Inquirer : So the Prophet Pbuh never actually said to replace the 100 lashes of the Quranic punishment for adultery with stoning.
Mullah pet : If his companions said so it is good enough for me.(classified as anyone who saw the Prophet Pbuh)
Inquirer : Since Hadith literature is sold as not contradicting the Quran, what are the basis for changing the clearly worded verse on this particular subject?
Mullah pet : Abrogation of course
Inquirer : And in that case there must be dozens of Hadith to support this game changing notion of abrogation right?
Mullah pet : Well actually, no there are no Hadith to support abrogation but our Mullahs say so.
Inquirer: So basically what you are saying is that a group of Mullahs can in practice overrule the Quran ?
Mullah pet: You are a Kafir
Allaah guides whom he will's, if you truly believe what you are writing will attain for you the pleasure of Allaah and the betterment of Islam; sincerely question the moment you will meet the angel of death and will he congratulate you on this network you have created?
ReplyDeleteMy dear brother reflect before the point of accountability truly begins.
I pray to God constantly to guide me and I am certain that by pointing out innovations in our beautiful Deen, I am hoping more people will take the trouble to verify the Deen for themselves like I did.
DeleteThe main reason people are reluctant to challenge the tall claims of the Mullahs masquerading as "scholars" is that they have neither personally verified that Quran is the very word of God nor that the reports in the Hadith literature are the words of the Prophet Pbuh. Hence their reliance on others as opposed to personal verification has resulted in a belief system that is middle men centric while their account on the Day of Judgement will be an individual account.
If you find anything on my blog that is against the teachings of Islam, please point it out to me with proof and I will immediately remove it and ask for the forgiveness of our Rab.
Thank you for visiting my humble blog